Patrice Sweeny
1976 — Princess

Terri Morgan
1977 — Princess

Tamara Sweeney
1978 — Queen

Molly Parry
1979 — Princess

Beth Murphy
1980 — Princess

Maureen Dodroe
1981 — Princess

Trina Perry
1982 — Princess

Shannon Richey
1983 — Princess

Lyn Peterson
1984 — Princess

Seanna Crowley
1985 — Princess

Jeanne Nolan
1986 — Princess

Lisa Agnew
1987 — Princess

Tricia Jones
1988 — Princess

Sydney Sloan
1989 — Princess

Victoria Pace
1990 — Princess

Taryn Brinson
1991 — Princess

Tiffany Brickner
1992 — Queen

Jennifer O'Brien
1993 — Princess

Katie Shea
1994 — Princess

Tina Valentine
1995 — Princess

Angie Boyd
1996 — Princess

Tam Nguyen
1997 — Princess

Alyson Ryan
1998 — Princess

Melissa Murphy
1999 — Princess

Rachael Alyea
2000 — Princess

Sara Desautel
2001 — Princess

Jaunessa Wendel
2002 — Princess

Adriana Demakas
2003 — Princess

Vanessa Anderson
2004 — Princess

Lauren Doruth
2005 — Candidate

Maria Oliva
2006 — Candidate

Alyssa Henke
2007 — Princess

Kylie Berger
2008 — Candidate

Meg Cressey
2010 — Princess

Emily Staker
2013 — Princess

Briony Denker
2014 — Candidate

Aitanna Ferrez
2015 — Princess

Kristiana Kershaw
2016 — Princess

August Corppetts
2017 — Queen

Natalie Schwartzenberger
2018 — Ambassador

Shayla Troy
2019 — Ambassador

Katelyn Bahr
2020 — Princess

Julia McIntyre
2021 — Queen

Ryan Ham
2022 — Princess

Aidyn Whitehead
2023 — Princess

Kwynci Peters
2024 — Princess

Clare League
2025 — Candidate

Naliesha Richardson
2026 — Princess